That noise was fully undeserved, and Tony protested with pursed lips and both hands spread open to receive any indication that it was his fault for being right this whole time. Tommy definitely wasn't producing any strong arguments, instead seemed to be debating for the wrong side. It wasn't that Billy was homophobic now, and it wasn't even that he was straight, and it couldn't be the age, it was just the broadly appealing choice of gift that Billy happened to not be impressed by. Tony complained, "Sure, it's my fault that I don't know your boyfriend's tastes intimately enough. Stay here, I'll go blow him, then we'll both be ready for this conversation."